Research discussion paper reserve bank of australia rba. The disease was first identified in the united states in 1930. Dutch disease is a paradoxical situation where good news for one sector of the economy, such as the discovery of natural resources, results in a negative impact on the countrys overall economy. Modeling the impact of australias mining boom on tourism. The deindustrialization of a nations economy that occurs when the discovery of a natural resource raises the value of that nations currency, making manufactured goods less competitive with other nations, increasing imports and decreasing exports. This gap is important as australia is sometimes assumed to be a case of a mining boominduced dutch disease. According to the theory of dutch disease the core model, proposed by corden and neary 1982 and corden 1984, resource. They see australia as suffering from a form of dutch disease. While much resource literature focusing 1 dutch disease may be defined in many ways. The uk process of deindustrialisation was sped up by the. One restaurant coowner said, we cant just turn off the fridges for half a day. Dutch disease refers to the adverse effects through real exchange rate appreciation that such a boom can have on various export and importcompeting industries. The population of 26 million is highly urbanised and heavily concentrated on the eastern seaboard. To further enrich the stock of literature on the dutch disease phenomenon.
The erosion of the price competitiveness of destination australia associated with exchange rate appreciation has adversely affected inbound and domestic. Appreciation of reer, high inflation rate between 2008 and 2011, balance of trade deficit and a declining manufacturing sector, one would argue that dutch disease does occur during this period. Dutch disease is a concept used to explain the apparent. Many african countries have also struggled to enable rising living standards after the discovery of oil. The dutch disease model may describe the flows of treasures into spain and portugal in 16th century or australian gold rush in the 1850s. Rajan and arvind subramanian december 2009 we examine the effects of aid on the growth of manufacturing, using a methodology that exploits the variation within countries and across manufacturing sectors, and corrects for. In recent times, concerns about dutch disease in australia have.
If youre looking for evidence of dutch disease, the shrinking of manufacturing and other sectors outside of energy and mining, australia has suffered a lot more than canada over the last 15. A wellknown paper, published five years later, identified other means by which commodity booms cause economic trouble. Dutch disease the phenomenon in which the manufacturing sector of a country declines when it begins to make significant profits from the exploitation of a natural resource. American economists have for years doled out advice to dutch diseasestricken nations, extolling the virtues of balanced economic growth, with the tacit assumption that the united states is advanced, diversified, and large enough to avoid the pitfalls of reliance on wealth from minerals. It is primarily associated with a natural resource. The dutch disease argument suggests that in commodity exporting countries overvaluation of the currency due to increases in commodity prices harms manufacturing even though the economy as a whole may bene. Other economists have tested this theory empirically, often on a national, onecountry level. The dutch disease term was first introduced in the economist magazine in 1977 to analyze the economic. The australia tourism industry faces challenges associated with a boom in minerals exports. Does the canadian economy suffer from dutch disease. Saying the evening hours were the best for business, retailers protested. Thus, australia is experiencing a typical dutch disease situation corden, 2012. Lowe of the reserve bank of australia has argued that australia is unlikely to suffer from dutch disease, instead seeing the mining construction boom as part of a structural adjustment the process of development in asia is going to take many decades, and australia has to supply the resource needs to asia for a number of decades. In 1970s the same development as in norway we can find in great.
Kutan and wyzan 2005 find that significant dutch disease symptoms are present in kazakhstan. We estimate that anufactm uring output in 20 was about 5 per cent below what it would have been wthout the i boom. Australias economy is at risk of suffering dutch disease unless federal and state governments can lessen their reliance on international debt, the future funds david murray has warned. The fear of deindustrialization linked to the dutch disease did not materialize in the netherlands. This is a term from the 1970s which is perhaps not so familiar now, yet it is quite relevant in a world where many countries have seen their economies boosted by high natural resources exports. The exchange rate, dutch disease and manufacturing in. Egert and leonard 2006 find less significant dutch disease symptoms but find support for. Dutch disease refers to the adverse effects through real exchange rate appreciation that such a boom can have on various export and importcompeting.
The economic mechanisms behind the dutch disease have also been at work in norway. The economist explains what dutch disease is, and why it. Economists have named this paradox the dutch disease, which refers to the impact on a countrys exchange rate once it starts selling a valuable commodity, like oil, on the international market. To answer it, one would have to involve the concept of significant reductions in norwegian manufacturing sectors in excess of the normal displacement all industrialized countries experience. From the late 1960s onwards, the dutch exports of nongas industries have increased sensibly.
Dutch disease definition, disadvantages, and how to avoid. Australia and the dutch disease simon taylors blog. New york times best selling author of the paleo cure using genetic testing is an excellent way to demonstrate susceptibility. Dutch disease is an economics term that refers to the negative consequences arising from large increases in the value of a countrys currency. The world economic forum is an independent international organization committed to improving the state of the world by engaging business, political, academic and other leaders of society to shape global, regional and industry agendas. A spike in inflation and significant rise in imports are key indicators for dutch disease. For example, if a country suddenly discovers oil and sells it on the international market, it may see a decline in the competitiveness of its manufacturing companies. Article pdf available in annals of tourism research 46. The term dutch disease was first coined by the economist in 1977 to describe the decline in netherlands manufacturing after the discovery of gas fields in the early 1960s. Dutch disease synonyms, dutch disease pronunciation, dutch disease translation, english dictionary definition of dutch disease. Dutch disease financial definition of dutch disease. Furthermore most studies on oil booms have focused mainly on its effect on manufacturing and to a lesser extent agriculture corden, 1984, which is the focus of this paper. A final caveatactually a compliment for modesty of ambition.
Disease effects that can turn mining boom into a resource curse. Pdf australia has experienced several episodes of mining boom in its. The implications of global economic transformations for australia. Dutch is a complete game changer in the functional medicine landscape, and far superior to saliva hormone testing in most circumstances. Australian processing industries that were intensive in low skilled manual.
Although most agree that it had a positive effect on the australian economy as well as on peoples living standards, there is disagreement over the. In economics, the dutch disease is the apparent causal relationship between the increase in. A diagnosis regarding whether a country is experiencing the dutch disease as a result of large oda inflows carries important policy implications and, hence, should be based on a careful. It is usually difficult to be certain that a country has dutch disease because it is. As large amounts of foreign exchange flood in, the value of the countrys own currency rises. I have not scrutinized rajan and subramanians regressions closely, but aart kraay at the world bank did four years ago and his critiques may still apply.
Azerbaijans economy, drunk on oil, is suffering rapid inflation, the economist, 2007 diagnosing dutch disease. Unless they can provide their own power, 100 shopping malls will have to close from p. It is the largest country in oceania and the worlds sixthlargest country by total area. For example, ruehle and kulkarni 2011 study potential dutch disease. The dutch disease in australia policy options for a threespeed. A federal eradication campaign in the late 1930s and early 40s sharply reduced the numbers of infected elms but could. Australia, officially the commonwealth of australia, is a sovereign country comprising the mainland of the australian continent, the island of tasmania, and numerous smaller islands. This paper expounds the concept of dutch disease as it applies currently to australia, noting the various gains and losses resulting from the australian mining boom. Dutch elm disease is caused by three species of ascomycete fungi in the genus ophiostoma. Dutch disease is analysed in a novel context with tourism. For dining establishments it had to be a nightmare. Abstract dutch disease refers to the adverse effects through real exchange rate appreciation that the mining boom can have on various. Russia is the largest exporter of natural gas and the second largest exporter of oil in the world, accounting for 68% of the countrys total exports in 2012. How to avoid the dutch disease world economic forum.
In the model, there is a nontradable sector which includes services and two tradable sectors. Previous research our analysis builds on a large body of, much of which is by australian research academics, on the dutch disease. Impact and causes of illness and death in australia 2011, a landmark report that presents burden of disease estimates, tailored for their relevance to the australian population and health system context. Dutch disease definition of dutch disease by the free. Australia has experienced several episodes of mining boom in its economy. That damaged manufacturing output, a phenomenon the economist magazine termed dutch disease the symptoms should sound familiar.
This study does not and cannot assess the overall impact of aid on economic growth. The first paper regarding this relationship in australia was written by meade and russell 1957. University of new south wales, new south wales, australia. The booming sector is usually the extraction of natural resources such as oil, natural gas, gold, copper. In the 1970s, the netherlands enjoyed a north sea gas boom that pushed the value of the dutch guilder through the roof. Incorporated as a notforprofit foundation in 1971, and headquartered in geneva, switzerland, the forum is tied to no political, partisan or national interests. Since that article, economists have proposed other dutchdisease effects. Examining dutch disease across australian regions shafiullah. Aid, dutch disease, and manufacturing growth forthcoming in the journal of development economics raghuram g. The dutch disease is a resource reallocation process away from less pro. Meanwhile, norway s total exports have been stagnant relative to gdp at a level well below that of the netherlands, even if the. Wage costs have increased considerably relative to trading partners, partly due to higher nominal wage growth and partly due to an appreciation of the norwegian krone. A study of the resourcerich australian and norwegian economies has shown.
17 818 670 481 178 1155 381 1013 1042 1476 1260 429 1029 419 232 1375 89 445 1189 1106 759 1334 24 1240 53 788 435 1319 1477 1364